West End Investment Market
Surprise inflation figures and another quarter point rise in interest rates have not helped the West End market this quarter, with one of the lowest volumes on record.
£1.1bn
of stock currently under offer
We recorded just 13 transactions totalling £375M of volume either exchanged or exchanged and completed in the first three months of 2023. To put this in context, if we take the 10 year Q1 average, it stands at £1.4Bn and 25 transactions – so we are running at 25% of typical volumes. Q1 2022 was also around £1.4Bn.
There are some key takeaways if we analyse the transactions that have occurred, but before we set these out, it is worth pointing out that the historically low volume probably isn’t representative of the West End market as we are tracking around £1.1Bn of stock currently under offer.
Much like the Railways have in the past blamed “the wrong type of snow”, we seem to have the “wrong type of stock”. Quality core buildings with income are selling well. Pontegadea bought 33 Foley Street in March off Abrdn who launched the asset for sale in January. The freehold building was let to Kier (who have sublet entirely) until December 2042 at c £90psf with RPI reviews. The price paid - £82M and 4.3% is probably close to a record for Fitzrovia at just over £1,900 per sqft. Similarly assets that are now under offer – Film House on Wardour Street, and 20 Rathbone Place both represent high quality assets which have attracted significant interest. However there is a notable absence of similar buildings on the market.
Q1 2023 has missed out on any major transactions to bolster the numbers - the largest transaction being on the seemingly unflappable Bond Street where Chanel sold No 27, let to Alexander McQueen and Chanel, for £140M reflecting 2.64% net yield. Along with Foley Street these two transactions made up 60% of the volume for the quarter.
After Allsop’s sale of 7 Ridgmount which exchanged before Christmas but completed in March, the most closely watched value add opportunity was at 55 Tottenham Court Road. This comprises a Freehold c 50,000 sqft block with the Ground Floor let to M&S Simply Food, and the vacant uppers representing an opportunity to refurbish and extend the 32,000 sqft former police station into offices. There was consent to change the use back to offices, but the additional massing was proposed but not consented. The building was launched to market in July 2022 for £52.0M £1,032 per sqft and placed under offer over the summer. Following Liz Truss’s short stint as PM and the ensuing turmoil, the buyer pulled out. Perhaps symptomatic of the market sentiment, the vendors failed to attract interest for the rest of the year, then in January indicated a c 15-20% price drop would be considered – which resulted in “best bids”. The Ofer Family’s Global Holdings ultimately bought the asset for £41M in late February representing £820 per sqft and around a 20% discount. Rents have remained strong, and construction costs inflation is probably close to peaking, so the discount in pricing can be entirely explained through a change in exit yield on buyers’ development appraisals largely driven by the change in cost of money.
Some key takeaway’s of the quarter’s transactions are:
- All 13 purchases we have tracked were by or on behalf of private investors.
- Retail-led investments made up over half the total volume – relatively unprecedented.
- Only 33 Foley Street was actually launched to market in 2023 – the rest launched in 2022 or even earlier.
- 7 of the 13 deals were under £15m lot size – where there seems to be greater liquidity.
- 95% by value was for Freehold or Virtual Freehold assets – perhaps unsurprising given the weight of private investor money and their aversion to geared leaseholds.
£6bn
of asset in 84 opportunities
Looking forward
We estimate around c £1.1Bn “under offer” including Westbourne Terrace and Haymarket House making up c £330m. Again, underlining the relative skew towards retail-led assets, McDonalds at 25 Shaftesbury Avenue, Vodafone at 341 Oxford Street, 32/33 Old Bond Street and 126-134 Baker Street are also under offer for a combined £200M.
We have seen the return of invitations to best bids which was relatively rare in the second part of 2022 “post Truss”. These include 55 Strand, HCA Hospital Great Portland Street, Royal College Place King’s Cross, all invited offers during April, with a further 8 properties going to informal best bids during March.
Looking at current supply in the West End we are tracking circa £6Bn of asset in 84 opportunities either on the open market or withdrawn (but in many cases still buyable)….
Through our mandate with Citi Private Bank, we are seeing a significant uptick in interest from Middle Eastern Capital as long term average pricing continues to adjust. There is continued interest from Asia capital which we are seeing through our tie-up with Millennium Group - in particular in the City market.
Ending on a positive, there remains a significant weight of capital allocated to Central London real estate from most parts of the globe. Given the stock under offer and going to bids, Q2 and Q3 should paint a very different picture in terms of volume. As our leasing colleagues point out, the office occupational market appears to be in good health.